Start with Supreme or Elite when a $0 general in-network deductible is your priority. Both offer that starting point, but Supreme has a lower individual in-network out-of-pocket maximum. Their higher-tier prescription benefits also work differently: Supreme uses scheduled dollar copays where Elite uses member-paid percentages. Those distinctions can matter more to your choice than the shared deductible. The medical figures are on PDF page 22 of Supreme and Elite; their prescription terms are on page 24.
Prime 100 and Prime 500 offer another comparison: both generally pay 80% of covered in-network medical expenses, but their deductibles, office-visit copays and individual out-of-pocket limits differ. The figures below show where to look before choosing between them.
Four specific plans, one comparison scope
This article compares only the four 2026–2027 policy numbers below, which name the UHC Choice Plus PPO network. It does not describe Supreme California, Elite California, Basic or every Student Medicover product. Match your enrollment option to the correct certificate and confirm your eligibility and your school's acceptance of outside coverage before purchasing.
Here, in-network means Preferred Provider. Benefits apply to covered expenses under the certificate's conditions, exclusions and service-specific limits. Page references count from the PDF cover; PDF pages 22–25 are the printed Schedule of Benefits pages 1–4.
Medical cost sharing: read three figures together
The deductible and out-of-pocket maximum below are per insured person, per policy year. Each source link identifies PDF page 22 for that entire row.
| Plan and policy number | In-network deductible | General plan share* | Individual in-network out-of-pocket maximum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supreme · 2026-203659-91 · p.22 | $0 | 90% | $5,000 |
| Elite · 2026-203783-91 · p.22 | $0 | 90% | $6,350 |
| Prime 100 · 2026-203113-91 · p.22 | $100 | 80% | $6,350 |
| Prime 500 · 2026-203113-92 · p.22 | $500 | 80% | $7,350 |
The percentage is the plan's general share of covered medical expenses, based on the Allowed Amount, except where a benefit specifies otherwise. For a Preferred Provider, the Allowed Amount is the contracted fee, as defined on PDF page 13 of each certificate.
A deductible tells you what must be met where that deductible applies. Coinsurance tells you how eligible costs are shared. A $0 deductible removes the general in-network deductible, but does not eliminate copays or coinsurance. Nor does a $500 deductible mean that every service requires you to meet it first: the Prime plans have specific exceptions, including the physician-visit benefit discussed below.
Why it changes the choice: Supreme and Elite are useful starting points when you want to avoid a general in-network deductible. Choosing between them still requires comparing other benefits. With Prime 100 and Prime 500, the shared 80% general plan share does not erase their other cost-sharing differences.
The out-of-pocket maximum answers a separate question: how much qualifying personal cost sharing can accumulate before covered expenses are paid at 100% for the remainder of the policy year, subject to benefit limits. Applicable deductibles, copays and coinsurance count toward it. Noncovered expenses and reductions for failing to meet policy requirements do not. In-network and out-of-network maximums are separate. These rules appear on page 22 of all four certificates.
Supreme has the lowest individual in-network maximum among these four plans. That is relevant when you prioritize limiting qualifying cost sharing in a year with substantial covered care. It is not a cap on your entire healthcare budget, including premiums and noncovered services, or proof of the lowest total cost.
Doctor visits: a deductible is not the whole appointment
The in-network outpatient physician-visit benefit combines a copay with a specified plan share of the Allowed Amount. Supreme, PDF p.24, lists a $20 copay and 90% plan share. Elite, PDF p.23, lists a $25 copay and 90% plan share. Prime 100, PDF p.23, lists a $25 copay and 80% plan share; Prime 500, PDF p.23, lists a $75 copay and 80% plan share. Both Prime physician-visit benefits are expressly not subject to the deductible.
For repeat office visits, Prime 100 offers a lower scheduled physician-visit copay than Prime 500 while retaining the same 80% plan share for that benefit. That is a reason to prioritize Prime 100 in the comparison when visit cost sharing matters to you. Elite and Prime 100 illustrate another distinction: the same physician-visit copay does not mean the same overall benefit. The plan-share percentages differ. Additional tests or services can fall under separate benefit rows, so the copay should not be read as the entire appointment cost.
Urgent care has its own terms. Supreme and Elite list a $50 copay with a 90% plan share; Prime 100 lists $50 with 80%; Prime 500 lists $75 with 80%. The Prime urgent-care benefits are not subject to the deductible. These figures are on PDF page 25 of Supreme, Elite, Prime 100 and Prime 500. The benefit covers the urgent-care facility or clinic fee; other services follow their own benefit provisions, as specified on PDF page 11 of each certificate.
Prescriptions: fixed copays and percentages are different choices
The table shows your scheduled share at a UnitedHealthcare Pharmacy (UHCP) retail network pharmacy for up to a 31-day supply per covered prescription. Unlike the medical percentages above, these prescription percentages are paid by the member.
| Plan and source | Tier 1 | Tier 2 | Tier 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supreme · PDF p.24 | $15 copay | $30 copay | $50 copay |
| Elite · PDF p.24 | $15 copay | 30% coinsurance | 50% coinsurance |
| Prime 100 · PDF p.24 | $15 copay | 30% coinsurance | 50% coinsurance |
| Prime 500 · PDF p.24 | $25 copay | 30% coinsurance | 50% coinsurance |
Elite and both Prime plans expressly exclude this retail prescription benefit from the deductible; Supreme's general in-network deductible is $0. These terms are in the same page-24 benefit entries and page-22 deductible schedules.
Why it changes the choice: For a covered Tier 2 or Tier 3 medication, Supreme offers a fixed scheduled copay to compare against the percentage-based sharing in the other three plans. That can be useful when you prefer a defined dollar contribution for qualifying refills.
Check the medication itself, not just its broad category. Each certificate's UHCP endorsement addresses coverage and lower-of-charge rules on PDF page 53, supply limits on page 54, prior authorization on page 55 and tier placement on page 56. The scheduled copay is not necessarily the actual charge: the retail rules use the lowest applicable amount among scheduled cost sharing, the pharmacy's usual charge and the defined Prescription Drug Charge. Tier placement can change.
Preventive care: a shared benefit with a specific definition
All four plans cover qualifying preventive care from Preferred Providers at 100% of the Allowed Amount, with no deductible, copay or coinsurance. Their preventive benefit provides no out-of-network benefits. See PDF page 25 of Supreme, Elite, Prime 100 and Prime 500.
The definition on PDF page 10 of each certificate limits this benefit to qualifying services under the plan's preventive-care guidelines. An appointment described as a physical or checkup does not automatically make every test or service eligible for this treatment.
For your choice, the important point is that this preventive benefit is shared by the Prime plans as well as Supreme and Elite. A preference for eligible in-network preventive care alone does not distinguish the four; prescriptions, visit charges and qualifying out-of-pocket exposure may do more to separate them.
Turn the differences into a personal shortlist
Within the two $0-deductible options, compare Supreme and Elite on higher-tier prescription cost sharing and the individual in-network out-of-pocket maximum. Between the Prime plans, Prime 100 lists a lower deductible and lower physician-visit copays than Prime 500. Use those differences alongside the current premium for your own coverage period, your medications and your expected care.
Bring your current medications, preferred providers and required coverage dates to the plan-selection page. Use the Certificate Index for complete documents. For the broader provider decision, the international student health insurance provider guide provides the category-level comparison.
